WARNING: This post contains spoilers. If you have not yet seen the movie, The Pursuit of Happyness, please read on as I want to invite you NOT to see it. Here's why. (I have also added a post script to encourage you to see a film you have already decided NOT to see, and for the wrong reasons.
Only people who do not own a TV for religious reasons or live in a public bathroom do not know by now that Will Smith's new movie, The Pursuit of Happyness, is based on the true life experiences of Chris Gardner. (It is misspelled in the title, with a "y.") Gardner is a struggling salesman who gets a shot at working in a big stock brokerage, as an unpaid intern, and is hired by the firm. He goes on to become one of the most successful brokers in the history of Dean-Whitter. He then goes on to start his own brokerage firm and become a multi- multi- millionaire. Along the way he assists other struggling-with-life folks and becomes an inspiration to thousands. That story would be a great movie. Unfortunately, that is not the story they tell in this movie.
THIS movie focuses on the struggles -- domestic and professional -- leading to his internship at Dean-Whiter. That is ALL the movie focuses on, THE STRUGGLE: bad marriage, terrible sales job (expensive product that no one wants), financial struggles-a-plenty, and slogging those now-famous San Francisco hills. We're walking, we're walking. . .
Watching this movie is grueling, exhausting, and not Happy, ever!
The happy part--Chris Gardner making it big (HUGE)--well, it NEVER ARRIVES, on screen. It shows up at the end of the movie as a printed paragraph about his success. Words. They make us read the happiness not experience it. This is terrible storytelling. It is a rotten movie going experience (on Christmas night!) They might as well have flashed the words:
And they live happily ever after.
After dragging us through far too many scenes of Will Smith (Gardner) and his little son (played by Smith's real life son) walking, and catching buses, and walking, and riding BART (Bay Area Rapid Transit), and walking, and running, and (did I mention) walking (mostly up hill), Will gets the job and goes on to blah, blah, blah, make a lot of money. (Cue credit roll)
Were the film makers afraid to tell a story that ends in grand, financial success? Maybe. But there is so much more to what the real Chris Gardner accomplished with his success. Now that would have been a great Act III to this unfinished, unsatisfying, unbearably dreary, depressing, and sad movie.
Great movies have an emotional impact on us in more than one direction.
In an action/adventure movie the villain spends a hefty chunky of the movie pursuing, tormenting, or torturing the hero and others. We can't wait for the good guy to catch the villain and get even. But if the bad guy is quickly arrested and dispatched into the custody of the authorities, or shot and dies instantly, without suffering, we are unsatisfied. We need the bad guy to suffer for a while to pay for all the suffering we went through with the hero.
The Pursuit of Happyness pulls us along as the hero suffers, and is tortured by his life, his wife, and the twin obstacle courses of corporate and governmental bureaucracy. We need an emotional payoff. This movie gives us nothing in exchange for our exhaustion. Words on the screen are not enough happiness for all we've been through. It is not enough that we sort of know the ending of this raggedness-to-riches story going in. TELL ME THE WHOLE STORY and tell it well.
The Pursuit of Happyness, the real story of Chris Gardner, is a great story. The movie fails to tell that story--the full story. See any other movie this season. (If you've already seen this movie and enjoyed it, somehow, well, you are a far better person than I.) You see, there's more to Chris Gardner's story than that he made lots of money. The story they didn't tell would have been a great film, an uplifting film, an inspiring, and transforming film. But THAT film is in another theatre. When you go the movies this holiday season, see that other movie.
The REAL Pursuit of Happiness
After re-reading my post above, I realized I have already seen a great film this movie-going season. It, too, is the story of a man struggling to create a life for his wife and young son whom he loves dearly. It begins with the gentle and warm images of his place in a healthy, vibrant community. The men work together to provide for their families and their interaction is collegial and even playful as they pull practical jokes on one another. When they return home together, the entire community comes to welcome them. The early scenes paint a picture (it is a visually stunning film) of a graceful and humane life.
Then, suddenly and harshly, their tranquil lives are shatter, invaded. Thus begins a relentless and grueling ordeal. It is at once difficult, fascinating, and thrilling to experience. Our "hero" is thrust into circumstances not of his choosing. He is taken to a world beyond his imaginings--and ours. But it is a real world, based on true events, and the precise research of historical experts.
This story takes place before the discovery of North America and forms the basis for Mel Gibson's APOCALYPTO. This is a visually breath taking film and heroic human saga THIS is the film you must see this season, on the biggest movie screen you can find. (Do your homework, drive to the big city, it's worth it.) This movie, like The Pursuit of Happyness, drags us along in a agonizing struggle for freedom and human happiness. But, unlike Will Smith's missed-adventure, Apocalyto delivers a far more satisfying, and complete, storytelling experience. And , yes, as has been reported, it is violent. But no more bloody or cruel than the story requires, and certainly far LESS violent than your average Bruce Willis romp or an afternoon with any of Martin Scorsese 's friends in Casino, Gangs of New York, et al. In fact, Apocalyto is LESS violent than the National Geographic channel's Lunch with the Lions.
No film review, that I've read, even mentions the opening scenes that I describe above, where Gibson shows us the gentle and grace-filled lives of the Mayan people in their forest-bound villages. The great accomplishments of that civilization (that existed before the time of Christ) may also have contributed to their undoing--according to historians.
Just as the high priest, on top of the magnificent Mayan pyramid, removes the human heart of a sacrificial victim, Apocalypto is the story a man struggling to save his heart: his family and his village. His simple striving to provide them a good life is the real story, the whole story, of one man against overwhelming odds in an elegant pursuit of happiness.
{ 1,196 }